• Українська
  • English

< | >

Current issue   Ukr. J. Phys. 2017, Vol. 62, N 6, p.481-488
https://doi.org/10.15407/ujpe62.06.0481    Paper

Starkov V.N., Borshch A.A., Gandzha I.S., Tomchuk P.M.

Institute of Physics, Nat. Acad. of Sci. of Ukraine
(46, Prosp. Nauky, Kyiv 03028, Ukraine; e-mail: starkov@iop.kiev.ua)

Some Examples of Seemingly Plausible Interpretation of Experimental Results

Section: Optics, Lasers, and Quantum Electronics
Original Author's Text: Ukrainian

Abstract: Some examples of a seemingly plausible but wrong interpretation of experimental results have been considered on the basis of the theory of rigorous mathematical interpretation of experimental data. The ability of apparatus errors to significantly affect the measurement results in optical experiments is demonstrated. Ignoring this fact can result in erroneous conclusions concerning the physical nature of the optical phenomena under consideration.

Key words: optical experiment, apparatus errors, ill-posed problems, regularization method.


  1. W.K. Heisenberg. What is "apprehension" in theoretical physics. Priroda 4, 75 (1971) (in Russian).
  2. A.S. Davydov. Interpretation of the results of scientific research in the physics domain. Preprint XXXXXX (Institute of Theoretical Physics, Kyiv,1980) (in Russian).
  3. A.N. Tikhonov, V.Ya. Arsenin. Solutions of Ill-Posed Problems (Wiley, 1977).
  4. A. Bakushinsky, A. Goncharsky. Ill-Posed Problems: Theory and Applications (Kluwer, 1994).
  5. G.M. Vainikko, A.Yu. Veretennikov. Iteration Procedures in Ill-Posed Problems (Nauka, 1986) (in Russian).
  6. V.N. Strakhov. Critical analysis of the classical theory of linear ill-posed problems. Geofizika 3, 3 (1999) (in Russian).
  7. V.N. Strakhov. Geophysical "Dialect" of Mathematic Language (OIFZ RAN, 2000) (in Russian).
  8. V.N. Strakhov. On the Training of Specialists in the Field of Gravity Prospecting and Magnet Prospecting at Higher Educational Institutions of Russia (OIFZ RAS, 2000) (in Russian).
  9. V.N. Strakhov. Geophysical version of the theory of regularization of linear ill-posed problems. In Problems of the Theory and Practice of the Geological Interpretation of Gravitational, Magnetic, and Electric Fields (Institute of Geophysics of NASU, OIFZ RAS, 2001), p. 99 (in Russian).
  10. V.N. Strakhov. Basic constructive ideas used at the development of numerical methods for finding stable approximate solutions of the systems of linear algebraic equations with an approximately given right-hand side, which arise in the gravimetry and magnetometry problems. I. Constructive ideas of the fundamental level. Fizika Zemli 11, 3 (2001) (in Russian).
  11. V.N. Strakhov. On the problem of regularization of the systems of linear algebraic equations that arise in the gravimetry and magnetometry problems. I. New constructive ideas. In Actual Problems of Mathematical Geophysics (OIFZ RAN, 2001), Vol. 1, p. 69 (in Russian).
  12. V.N. Strakhov. Paradigm Change in the Theory of Linear Ill-Posed Problems (OIFZ RAN, 2001) (in Russian).
  13. V.N. Strakhov, A.V. Strakhov. On regularization of the least-squares method. Geofiz. Zh. 20, N 6, 18 (1998) (in Russian).
  14. V.N. Strakhov, A.V. Strakhov. Generalization of the leastsquares method and regularized algorithms for finding stable approximate solutions of the systems of linear algebraic equations with approximate data that arise, while solving geophysical problems. Geofiz. Zh. 21, N 2, 3 (1999) (in Russian).
  15. V.N. Strakhov. Generalization of M.M. Lavrent'ev and A.N. Tikhonov variational methods for the regularization of the systems of linear algebraic equations with an approximately given right-hand side, which provides the requirements of gravimetry and magnetometry. Geofiz. Zh. 24, N 5, 3 (2002) (in Russian).
  16. V.N. Strakhov, A.V. Strakhov. Universal algorithms for the regularization of the systems of linear algebraic equations with an additive interference on the right-hand side, which arise at the solution of the gravimetry and magnetometry problems. Fizika Zemli 10, 3 (2000) (in Russian).
  17. Q. Yang, J.T. Seo, S.J. Creekmore, D.A. Temple, K.P. Yoo, S.Y. Kim, S.S. Jung, A.G. Mott. I-scan measurements of the nonlinear refraction and nonlinear absorption coefficients of some nanomaterials. In Proc. SPIE 4797, 101 (2003).
  18. I. Dancus, V.I. Vlad, A. Petris, T.B. Rujoiu, I. Rau, F. Kajzar, A. Meghea, A. Tane. Z-Scan and I-Scan methods for characterization of DNA optical nonlinearities. Rom. Rep. Phys. 65, 966 (2013).
  19. G. Boudebs, K. Fedus. Image formation and applications to third order nonlinear optical measurement. In Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Transparent Optical Networks (ICTON) (2012), p. 1.
  20. R.F. Souza, M.A. Alencar, J.M. Hickmann, R. Kobayashi, L.R. Kassab. Femtosecond nonlinear optical properties of tellurite glasses. Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 171917 (2006).
  21. T.B. Rujoiu, A. Petris, V.I. Vlad. Nonlinear refractive properties of 1D periodically nanostructured silicon-on-insulator investigated by reflection I-Scan. In Proc. SPIE 8882, 88820C (2013).
  22. T.B. Rujoiu, V.I. Vlad, A. Petris. Measurement of nonlinear refractive index of silicon nanostructures using reflection intensity scan method. Rom. Rep. Phys. 65, 954 (2013).
  23. V.I. Arnold. Mathematics and physics: a parent and a child or sisters? Usp. Fiz. Nauk 169, 1311 (1999) (in Russian).
  24. V.I. Starostenko, V.N. Starkov. On the results of verification of V.N. Strakhov hypothesis. Geofiz. Zh. 25, No. 1, 122 (2003) (in Russian).
  25. A.A. Borshch, V.N. Starkov, V.I. Volkov, V.I. Rudenko, A.Yu. Boyarchuk, A.V. Semenov. Optical confinement effects in thin nanostructured silicon carbide films. Kvant. Elektron. 43, 1122 (2013) (in Russian).
  26. A.A. Borshch, M.S. Brodyn, V.N. Starkov, V.I. Rudenko, V.I. Volkov, A.Yu. Boyarchuk, A.V. Semenov. Broadband optical limiting in thin nanostructured silicon carbide films and its nature. Opt. Commun . 364, 88 (2016).